Showing posts with label film review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label film review. Show all posts

Saturday, March 25, 2017

Logan (2017 film) and superhero violence

"There's no living with the killing..." -Shane (1953 film)

Throughout the 20th century, humankind gave birth to a class of genetic mutants with fantastic powers, who were generally hated and feared by ordinary humans. Now in the mid-21st century, mutant births have ceased, and most mutants have died out, along with the bloodshed done to and by them. Two surviving mutants are a clawed drifter named James Logan “Wolverine” Howlett and a telepath named Professor Charles Xavier, who once ran a school for young and exiled mutants. Logan is finally losing his ability to heal from any injury, and Charles’ advancing ALS is making his telepathy a danger to those around him. Together, with Logan as caregiver and Charles sliding into a second childhood, the two old men are quietly preparing to die in Mexico. But the discovery of an impossibly young mutant named Laura, with abilities and a temper much like Logan used to have, forces them into their last chance to be role models in a world that hated, then forgot them. The resulting journey is a test of how much they would sacrifice to save not the world, but one young life.

I don’t normally review movies, but this one deserves an entry for two reasons: it captivated me, and it gives me a chance to talk about superhero violence.

Superhero comics are an inescapable part of the body of modern speculative fiction. They have one key difference from novels, including most graphic novels: they are designed to continue forever. This requires them to embrace a bizarre marriage of predictability and ever-increasing flashiness in order to keep selling issues. (Or it did until comics became a way to market movies.) It also requires that superheroes always defeat their villains in the end. Typical comic book heroes refuse to kill their conquered villains both as a statement of moral superiority, and as an opportunity to recycle those villains in years to come.

Superhero movies are different. Because they are iterated with far less frequency than comic books, they pack their punch by killing the villain. Even the more moral heroes who, like Spider-Man in his first two film iterations, try to minimize casualties, are nevertheless burdened by a villain who accidentally dies as a result of his own hubris or sacrifices himself as an act of redemption. A notable exception to this rule is the X-Men’s Magneto, whose death would have martyred him.

Into this same franchise steps Logan, whose abandonment of the codename “Wolverine” has come with a humanizing of a character who, unusual among comics when he was first introduced, was unafraid and sometimes even eager to kill. He was animal-like by nature and enhanced to be a military weapon, leaving little room for any human personality but a gruff, cool exterior and the occasional current of passion for romance and saving innocent lives (by killing antagonists). In the movies, of which he has appeared in nine, his signatures are stabbing faceless foes with his unbreakable metal claws, and receiving sickening wounds that heal before he has a chance to bleed.

This changes in Logan, which features blood aplenty. The former Wolverine is old and tired. He does not eagerly leap into battle like superheroes are supposed to do. Of the three main characters, he is the most battle-hardened, yet actually the least deadly; Laura fights with sickening savagery, and Charles’ condition can cause him kill anyone around him regardless of moral categories. The audience is invited to question our own appetite for violence by sequencing the deadliness of these protagonists. Our opening scene features a drunk Logan beaten half to death before he sloppily dismembers his attackers. Charles’ first seizure is emotionally depressing, full of grating lights and sounds. Finally, once Laura bares her claws for the first time, we receive the heart-stopping, choreographed action we’ve learned to expect from a Wolverine movie—only to realize the scene we’ve been anticipating shows a child being gored with a harpoon, among other atrocities.


Kurt Vonnegut has written that writers should put their characters through hell in order to see what they’re made of. Logan does this to all its characters, “good” and “bad” alike, and many new sides surface to characters who have remained essentially the same for over a decade of films. It also does this to its viewers, who watch superhero movies to experience the catharsis of watching seemingly relatable characters perform incredible feats and beat the snot out of people who deserve it. I acknowledge that this kind of release is a major reason I enjoy comics. Logan does nothing of the kind, but it does offer the catharsis of knowing that no matter how bleak things get, redemption is always possible in the pursuit of simple acts of kindness for the people you least expect.

Wednesday, December 26, 2012

Review: The Hobbit, An Unexpected Journey (2012)

In a hole in the ground lives Bilbo Baggins: a hobbit, that is, a small, peaceful little man who lives comfortably in a beautiful land called the Shire in the world of Middle-Earth. All this (except his stature, I guess) changes when the wizard Gandalf appears and volunteers Bilbo to accompany a group of dwarves on a quest to reclaim their ancient home, the Lonely Mountain, from the fearsome dragon Smaug. Although he is initially very reluctant, Bilbo learns to grow into the role of the adventurer, gaining the respect of his brave companions. In the meantime, a dark being with power over death awakens in the heart of Middle-Earth.

Chances are you've read the book by Tolkien. Maybe you've also read The Lord of the Rings, or seen the movie. Here's the first thing to accept, for better or for worse: this movie is nowhere near as close to its book as The Lord of the Rings. The fact that this, too, is a trilogy probably clued you in, but this should clear up any lingering doubts.

It's not entirely like the LotR movies, either, but neither is Tolkien's The Hobbit. Written for children, there's a lot more whimsy involved in Bilbo's tale than in Frodo's. In the book, trolls and spiders talk and joke while they're trying to eat the main characters, swapping some gravitas for humor in order to keep Bilbo's character light. He's not a serious character, but that doesn't mean he isn't significant. Unfortunately, one fair weakness of the film is its portrayal of Bilbo. He begins firing off snappy one-liners far too early, without the right kind of development to show how he became used to the adventures of the road. If the film is going to deviate from the book, it should have some sense of depth to those who haven't read the book; otherwise it's using the book's elements in the wrong order.

Other deviations were more fun. Radagast, in particular, is definitely jumbled together from what fans would like to see rather than from Tolkien's notes, but that doesn't stop him from fairly bursting with the raucous balance between silliness and magic that this film works to achieve. And Azog's storyline is blatantly non-canon, but he works very well as a foe for the stubborn Thorin Oakenshield.

In every aspect other than plot and character, the film succeeds overwhelmingly. The visual aspect is totally breathtaking, as if LotR were painted with brighter colors so that it could shine from every crevice. My only complaint about that aspect is that some shots were a bit dizzying, even for someone who isn't normally averse to helicopter shots or shaky camera. But the musical score is fantastic, even better than its predecessors. For days afterward I found myself humming the dwarves' theme song in empty public restrooms (which have quite good acoustics).

Even if you're a loyal fan of the books or the movie trilogy, I recommend this film. After all, if you can look past the fact that Jackson now has a different approach to adaptation, he still comes up with gold. It's fun, which is the only real reason to go to the theater, anyway.

Thursday, June 28, 2012

Review: Brave (2012)

Look out! Spoilers! If you haven't yet seen this movie, you may not want to read further.


Brave, Pixar's most recent film, follows the adventures of the Scottish princess Merida, whose imminent betrothal drives her to a drastic attempt to break out of the fate imposed on her by society and by her mother, Queen Elinor. Because this is a primarily literary blog, I'm going to focus mostly on the plot and other elements that most directly affect the story. That said, the best way to summarize my opinion is to say that everything except the plot was nearly flawless. The animation, voice acting, music, and other elements I probably didn't notice all came together to make it a beautiful piece of cinema; that's unmistakable. It's a much bigger task to sort out the point of what actually happens.

Before seeing the movie, I had a plot predicted in my head. It was Brave as I would have written it, shaped by all the preview footage I had seen. In it, Merida begins as a stereotypical Disney princess: beautiful and strong-willed, but forced into a marriage she doesn't want. But she's made of sterner stuff than most Disney princesses, and rather than having her change handed to her by a ridiculous prince, she strikes a Faustian bargain with an evil witch, knowing full well that it will upset her kingdom, but not caring. Somehow her family is turned into bears, as the previews indicated, and the repercussions aren't as easy to face as she had anticipated. The climax of the movie would involve Merida, now having gained the knowledge of the consequences of her various actions, would learn to set aside her personal desires for the good of the kingdom. This could have involved a marriage, but preferably there would have been some other integral element.

The actual plot is much more haywire. To begin with, Merida is a lot more clueless than I had expected. In fact, she's downright idiotic. I'm aware that she's a teenager, but I think most of my high school class could have anticipated that, perhaps, the pastry brewed by the magical bear-themed villain might have something to do with turning the person who eats it into a bear! Lots of fairy tales involve hubris, but usually it's not nearly this specific or predictable. Many other parts of the film, including Merida's speech to the clan leaders, showed a similar pandering and lack of creativity. Pixar isn't usually a company that dumbs down its movies for a child audience, but I'm afraid that's what happened here.

Merida's parents, Queen Elinor and King Fergus, were very well done, and I especially enjoyed the Queen's personality when she becomes a bear. This middle part of the movie held me the most. Merida is aware of the damage she's done and is actively trying to repair it, and she and her mother are bonding in a creative way. It greatly helps this part that Elinor occasionally becomes "a bear on the inside, too," so that there's less silliness and more urgency.

The resolution was the sloppiest part. Things stop making sense in the last five minutes, after Mor'du dies. If legends are lessons, then the giant bear was the only thing keeping a sense of sanity tucked into this movie.

First: Merida completely forgets about the words the witch gave her to break the spell. If that was a message and not an incantation, it should not have been phrased that way, because it left the tapestry bit feeling like a cop-out.

Then she doesn't have to marry anybody, and all the clans go home happy. This means that there are no consequences, or in other words, that if you're angry about your betrothal, you can publicly humiliate your family by turning half of them into fuzzy animals and tricking your parents into trying to rend each other limb from limb. They will forgive you for everything, and all of your political allies will be too confused by the deus ex machina to remember why they sailed into the movie in the first place.

In the parting shot of the movie, one of our blue will-o-th'-wisp friends waves just to remind the audience that we have no idea of his motives. I guess this could be symbolic, but I'm not totally convinced.

There are plenty of core elements of this film that I enjoyed. The biggest one is that the plot is not driven by the machinations of a significant villain. This is true of fairy tales: the hero wanders into wacky events and leaves them having grown, as we do in real life. It was also primarily driven by women, which, though not intrinsically better in itself, is too lacking in the film world. And, of course, it was quite an adventure to watch, even while I remained skeptical of some of the plot devices. Even what I thought was flawed was enjoyable at the same time. I'd recommend this movie to anybody, as long as you're not looking for the same kind of moral weight Pixar put into Wall-E.